South Africa Summons Fani-Kayode Over Ramaphosa Ceremony Row, Warns Against Diplomatic Breach

By Ayo Kehinde

South Africa has summoned Nigeria’s High Commissioner, Femi Fani-Kayode, over the diplomatic controversy surrounding his presentation of letters of credence to President Cyril Ramaphosa and his subsequent public criticism of South African officials, warning him to respect established diplomatic procedures in his dealings with the host government.

The South African Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) disclosed this on Tuesday following a meeting between its Director-General, Zane Dangor, and the Nigerian envoy, during which Pretoria formally conveyed its concerns over the incident and Fani-Kayode’s subsequent remarks on social media.

The meeting followed days of public disagreement between the Nigerian High Commission and the South African Presidency over the handling of the diplomatic ceremony, with both sides offering conflicting accounts of the events.

In a statement, DIRCO said Dangor expressed South Africa’s displeasure over the circumstances surrounding the presentation of Fani-Kayode’s credentials to Ramaphosa and the comments that followed.

“During the meeting, the Director-General conveyed South Africa’s concern regarding events that transpired following the presentation of the High Commissioner’s Letters of Credence to His Excellency President Cyril Ramaphosa, as well as subsequent remarks made on social media,” the department said.

Dangor also emphasised the importance of preserving the longstanding relationship between Nigeria and South Africa, describing the partnership as one founded on mutual respect, friendship and cooperation.

In what represents the central message of the meeting, South Africa drew attention to Article 41 of the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which sets out the obligations of diplomatic representatives in their dealings with receiving states.

The provision requires diplomats to respect the laws and regulations of their host countries and conduct official business with the receiving government through its Ministry of Foreign Affairs or another ministry agreed upon by the parties.

DIRCO said Dangor specifically reminded Fani-Kayode of the requirement to use established diplomatic channels when communicating with the South African government.

“In this regard, it was emphasised that all official communication should be conducted through established diplomatic channels, including DIRCO,” the statement added.

The department did not announce any disciplinary measure against the Nigerian envoy but made clear South Africa’s position on the procedures governing official diplomatic engagement.

It nevertheless reaffirmed Pretoria’s commitment to strengthening its strategic partnership with Nigeria and maintaining constructive relations based on African solidarity and mutual respect. 

The disagreement originated at a diplomatic ceremony on Friday at the Presidential Guest House in Pretoria, where Ramaphosa received the letters of credence of Fani-Kayode and representatives of 14 other countries.

The presentation of letters of credence is a formal diplomatic procedure through which newly appointed ambassadors and high commissioners are accredited to their host countries and authorised to represent their respective governments.

However, the ceremony became contentious after Fani-Kayode alleged that the South African Presidency deliberately excluded the introduction of the Nigerian delegation and his speech from the official livestream.

The former Minister of Aviation claimed that the other 14 diplomatic representatives were formally introduced and their addresses transmitted, but the broadcast was interrupted when it was his turn to speak.

Taking to his X account after the event, Fani-Kayode wrote: “Every single one of the 15 Ambassadors that were present were introduced formally and gave a speech.

 Curiously, the South African Presidency refused to air the introduction of my goodself and the Nigerian delegation or to air my speech.”

He further alleged that the livestream was interrupted throughout his address and resumed only after he had concluded.

“They went a step further by cutting us out of the livestream completely and went back on livestream only after my speech was concluded,” he added.

Fani-Kayode described the alleged exclusion as unacceptable and disclosed that he personally raised the matter with Ramaphosa during a photograph session after the ceremony.

According to the Nigerian envoy, the South African President directed relevant officials to address his complaint.

He also revealed that he declined an interview request from the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC), explaining that he was dissatisfied with the treatment of the Nigerian delegation.

The allegations prompted a response from Ramaphosa’s spokesperson, Vincent Magwenya, who disputed Fani-Kayode’s account of the President’s intervention.

Magwenya said Ramaphosa had referred the Nigerian envoy to Sophie Mokoena, the SABC’s acting political and foreign editor, as the appropriate official to address his complaint.

He rejected any suggestion that the President could intervene in the broadcaster’s editorial decisions, stressing that the SABC operates independently.

“The SABC is a public broadcaster. The President carries no legal or political mandate to interfere with its operations or intervene in its editorial processes,” Magwenya said.

The presidential spokesperson also criticised the Nigerian envoy’s handling of the complaint, describing it as “grossly inappropriate”.

He maintained that Fani-Kayode had misunderstood the circumstances surrounding the broadcast, which he characterised as a minor operational issue.

Hours after the controversy emerged, the South African Presidency released a separate recording of Fani-Kayode’s speech on its official YouTube channel, making the address available after the envoy had complained about its omission from the original livestream.

The disagreement subsequently escalated into a public exchange between the Nigerian High Commission and Magwenya, with the mission defending Fani-Kayode and challenging the presidential spokesperson’s explanation.

The Nigerian mission maintained that Ramaphosa had intervened after the envoy brought the matter to his attention and faulted Magwenya for his public response.

It accused the spokesperson of bringing his country into disrepute and alleged that the Nigerian High Commissioner had been treated with contempt and disdain.

The mission argued that the disagreement should have been handled with greater restraint and through appropriate diplomatic engagement, rather than public exchanges capable of straining relations between the two countries.

It also urged both governments to protect their longstanding relationship and prevent the incident from undermining bilateral cooperation.

The meeting between Dangor and Fani-Kayode on Tuesday has now brought the disagreement into formal diplomatic engagement, with Pretoria stressing the importance of established procedures in resolving official grievances.

Nigeria and South Africa are two of Africa’s most influential countries, with longstanding diplomatic and economic ties covering trade, investment, security, regional integration and continental development.

Their relationship has, however, experienced periodic tensions, particularly over xenophobic attacks against Nigerians and other African nationals in South Africa, immigration restrictions and the treatment of foreign nationals.

Despite these disagreements, both countries have continued to engage through bilateral and multilateral platforms, recognising their importance to regional stability and the African continent.

The latest controversy has added another diplomatic disagreement to the relationship, with South Africa’s invocation of the Vienna Convention bringing the responsibilities of diplomatic representatives and the proper channels for official communication into focus.

While DIRCO reaffirmed Pretoria’s commitment to maintaining cordial relations with Nigeria, its meeting with Fani-Kayode underscores its insistence that the dispute should be addressed within the established framework governing diplomatic relations

Leave a Response